Page 73 - Industrial Plants
P. 73

suits the actual needs, even when external noise
                                                     control measures are applied. Vertical barriers or
                                                     enclosures, and other means aimed to limit noise
                                                     propagation can surely be helpful, but related
                                                     effectiveness should be evaluated case by case, by
                                                     considering any possible issues related to aesthetic
                                                     acceptability, as well.

                                                     While the industry is rising to the challenge, by
                                                     developing new products specifically designed for low
                                                     noise  applications,  the  ability  to  optimise  noise-
                                                     restricted projects by selecting the proper equipment
                                                     and applying for the most convenient control measures
                                                     is not widely employed in engineering field and practice.
                                                     The result is that the solutions applied to projects may
                                                     not always be the most cost effective solutions.


                                                     What is to be done when noise
                                                     becomes a challenge?

                                                     One of the dilemmas faced by Engineering and
                                                     Procurement Contractors (EPCs) while approaching
                                                     new  projects  is  whether  to  select  Intrinsically  Silent
                                                     equipment  or  standard  equipment  compensated  by
                                                     additional means of protection. In any case, a
                                                     comprehensive approach that takes into consideration
                                                     all the possible technical solutions and involves a joint
                                                     cooperation with the Equipment Manufacturer should
                                                     be preferred, especially when the requirements are
                                                     challenging. Only  the synthesis  of experience and
                                                     knowledge of both parties allow for the identification of
                                                     the most suitable and cost effective solution.


                                                     Air cooled heat exchangers as one

                                                     of the major contributor to noise
                                                     emission of industrial plants


                                                     Air cooled heat exchangers are a type of process
                                                     equipment used to cool down vapour or liquid flows by
                                                     transferring the associated heat to the ambient air. They
                         oise Control Requirements are   are composed of heat exchange sections where the
                         becoming increasingly stringent to   process fluid passes through finned tubes, and fan
                         preserve human wellness and health.   units used to push the ambient air for cooling.
                         This is particularly true in Europe
                         where the lack of space in crowded   Due to the intrinsic characteristics of this equipment,
            Nareas, and the resulting proximity of   they are often one of the major contributors to noise
            industrial plants to sensitive receptors (e.g. residential   emission of industrial plants. Unlike other plant’s
            areas,  hospitals,  etc.) has  pushed  governments and   equipment like pumps or machineries, air coolers are
            municipalities to take action. Hence, limitations have   installed  outdoor  in  the  open  field,  as  they  need  to
            been enforced by Law for both the exposure of workers   operate with large masses of ambient air. This makes it   General view of air
            to noise and to the emission at the surrounding areas,   almost impossible to completely shield and contain   coolers installation –
            with the effect that not all standard-noise equipment   related noise emitting parts like fans or transmissions.   Denmark
            (i.e., equipment whose noise level is 85 dBA @ 1 m)   In addition to this, air coolers are usually large pieces of   (Renco s.p.a.)

                                                                                    IndustrIal Plants - May 2022
                                                                                                                   71
   68   69   70   71   72   73   74   75   76   77   78